Block’s Indicator of Sustainable Growth

by Ray Block

Two years ago, the US House of Representatives passed the Waxman Markey Bill regulating greenhouse gases. Two years later, the Senate is still wrestling with its version of the same bill.

The latest version by Senators John Kerry, the Massachusetts 2004 defeated Democratic candidate for President and Joe Lieberman, the independent senator from Connecticut introduced the American Power Act.

However, unlike last year, when the US Senate was debating climate action, and there was a powerful supporter of the legislation in Lindsey Graham, the moderate Republican from South Carolina, who holds a significant influence among the moderates, this year the coalition for the legislation has no bipartisan support.

As a result, the bill has little chance of reaching a majority of 60, the magic number preventing a minority of opposition senators from a filibuster, delaying endlessly a vote on the floor of the chamber.

The bill would mandate a 17 per cent reduction in greenhouse gases from 2005 levels by 2020, and 83 per cent by 2050. As the New York Times Green blog pointed out on March 12 2010, there are concessions for every major player.

“Loan guarantees for nuclear plant operators, incentives for use of natural gas in transportation, exemptions from emissions caps for heavy industries, free pollution permits for utilities, modest CO2 limits for oil refiners and expansion of offshore drilling for those states willing to accept the risks.”

The likelihood of an expansion in offshore drilling comes at an unfortunate time, with BP’s devastating oil spill in the Gulf of Mexico, potentially the largest oil spill on record. Coastal states worried about how drilling off the coast of one state could affect their state would have the ability to veto drilling projects.

US Public opinion has increasingly downplayed fears of global warming. The opinion poll, Rasmussen Reports in its April 19 2010 release said that only 54 per cent of voters “still believe global warming is a serious problem,” with “48 per cent saying global warming is caused by long term planetary trends, and only 33 per cent blaming human activity.”

A May 10 2010 Rasmussen Reports said that even after the Gulf oil spill was the dominant news item on the web, TV newscasts and newspapers front pages, 58 per cent of respondents still favoured offshore drilling.

Still a big majority for Big Oil, but a 14 per cent drop from the larger 72 per cent majority in favour of offshore drilling after Barack Obama announced at the end of March, the US Government opening new areas to exploratory offshore drilling for the first time in more than two decades.

Reuters summed up on the US public’s wavering opinions (May 10 2010): “(The oil slick) hasn’t really reached the Gulf Coast yet. Let’s start counting now to see how many polls on these contentious issues arrive before (a) the spill is cleaned up and (b) the bill either becomes law or fails to gain congressional approval.”